SILT HAPPENS #98-6
A Journal of Incidents and Activities - Grand County, Utah Search and Rescue

Content by Bego Gerhart (1T836) ---> silteditor@gcsar.org

GCSAR Home "Silt Happens" Member Profiles Operations Statistics
Training Schedule

1/28/99 Map/GPS Things- Each officer makes a map problem- C (Bego)
2/1/99 Regular Meeting : Prep for Mock (LSAFC)
2/6/99 Mock disaster in "The North Woods" (LSAFC)
2/9/99 Patient Packaging and Fire House ropes- F (Packagers and Ropers)
2/25/99 Search Dogs- F (The Dogs, In person)
3/9/99 A hike up the Tram route: helmet, headlamp, harness- F (Bego)
3/9/99 A hike up the Tram route: helmet, headlamp, harness- F (Bego)
3rd or 4th week in March '99 Arches Rock Rescue- 4 days (Colin Smith, et. al.)
4/13/99 Boating 1- F (Brad)
4/19-23/99 The ISKY Rock Rescue (Ken Phillips)
4/22/99 Ropes - F (Rope people)
5/11/99 Ropes - F (Rope people)
5/27/99 Search Stuff (Colin Smith, NPS ???)
6/8/99 Mock thingy by The Disaster Brothers (Brad, Kenny and Archie)
6/24/99 Tracking
7/13/99  
7/22/99 Picnic with Archie, Michelle and the others
8/10/99 Boating 2- w/ Dive Team?- F (Brad)
8/26/99 Basic Survival Skills- F (In the field, 6 instructors @ 15 minutes each.)
9/14/99 Doug Squire LEPC - We should have Doug talk to us every year.
9/23/99  
10/12/99 Search Dogs 2- F
10/28/99 Something about hunting for hunting people (Hunting People)
11/9/99 CPR ("Bring a Date" night at the shed)
11/23/99 CPR & Nominations
12/14/99 Winter Stuff- Elections


********

SILT Back Issues
#98-5 (Sept-Oct 98)
#98-4 (July-Aug 98)
#98-3 (May-June 98)
#98-2 (Mar-Apr 98)
#98-1 (Jan-Feb 98)

#97-6 (Nov-Dec 97)
#97-5 (Sept-Oct 97)
#97-4 (July-Aug 97)
#97-3 (May-June 97)
#97-2 (Mar-Apr 97)
#97-1 (Jan-Feb 97)












The two most common elements in the universe are hydrogen and stupid.





















"Forgiveness is giving up the hope of a better past."





















"Remember: The entire universe, with one trifling exception, is composed of others."





















1 T 8:
Education is a journey, not a destination. Experience is a good school but the fees are high.






















Mayday:
From the French
" m’aidez" = help us.






















ENDURANCE
- by Alfred Lansing --
Antarctic adventure in "full conditions"
"For scientific discovery, give me Scott; for speed and efficiency of travel, give me Amundsen; but when disaster strikes and all hope is gone, get down on your knees and pray for Shackleton."






















Way Cool:
Check out www.maptech.com
Incidents 98-56 to 98-67 (November - December)

At the Annual GCSAR Christmas Party... ( and where were you Bego?)
Rescuer of the Year for 1998 : Jeff Davis (1T829)

OFFICERS FOR 1999
Commander: Frank Mendonca
Vice Commander: Kenny Allred
Training Officer: Bego Gerhart
Equipment Adjuster: Lloyd Shafer
Sec/Treas: Nancy May
Captain: Sam Lewis
Captain: Brad Mallory
Captain: Rex Tanner

Thanks Yous to:
THANKS YOUS to all the Training Instructors thruout the year. Frank, Brad, Kenny, Denise, Jennie, Kent, Daves, Michele, Jimmys, Kyle I., Tony, Kris, John, Rena, Sam, Nancy, George, Doug, Aug, Bego

THANKS YOUS This will be the end of year three (3) at Silt Happens. 109 pages of whatever it is we is. The office staff would like to say Thank You to all the contributors, writers, editors, poofreaders, critics, political assassins, pundits and riff-raff.

********** November 7, 1998 **********

98- 68 11- 7- 98 Search for Overdue Biker Kokopelli Trail IC = 1 T 9
A doctor from Denver left Loma at 9:20am Friday and was to meet his friend at Dewey at 4 pm. The friend waited for awhile at Dewey and then went to a motel in Grand Junction for the night. Originally paged Friday night, Kim 1T9 went driving around the Dewey-Sagers Wash area.

In the morning, GCSAR and BLM Ranger Lue responded to Hwy 128 and Sager’s Wash area. We sent 4WD units out to Fish Ford and the Cisco boat take-out areas. ATVs were sent from Sager’s Wash toward Fish Ford.

Meanwhile, Mesa County had 4WD units, mountain bikers and a fixed wing aircraft out on various parts of the Kokopelli Trail from Loma, Mack and Rabbit Valley. The Westwater Ranger was also out on an ATV, going east from the Westwater Ranger Station.

BLM Rangers had seen the missing biker in the Bitter Creek area at 2:30 pm Friday afternoon so it was decided that he couldn’t have made it into the Squaw Park area, west of 128.

Sam, the Lost Person Magnet, with Richard, found the biker in the Sager’s Wash area. He had followed the trail into a wash but had missed the exit out of the wash. That cost him a very cold night out.

Responders:  Frank, Dave M., Sam, Richard, Dave L.

Practice Safe Response
Search and Rescue responders are subject to all the signs and laws and safe driving habits as anyone else. If you hit something or someone, YOU are responsible. Have a SAR decal on your vehicle and turn on your flashers. And drive safely all the time. and If dispatch calls you directly, you must call the OIC to appraise him of the situation

********** November 10, 1998 **********

GCSAR meeting 11- 10- 98
Training: CPR and Bloodborne Pathogens

********** November 14, 1998 **********

11- 14- 98 Short Haul Team Training La Sal Mountains
We got permission from the Forest Service to train on USFS land and we agreed to stay away from the main ski area. So, on a religiously scenic day, we established an LZ along the Loop Road at 7,700 feet elevation and flew singly or in pairs to the top of the ridge northwest of TukNo (see the ski map by Barnes) at 10,400 feet.

From here we could view all of the south to west facing popular cross-country skier terrain in Gold Basin. A view directly into Talking Mtn Cirque. The NW Ridge to Tuk.

Comments: Might have been the prettiest flight I’ve ever taken. Flight path was 3.5 miles long. The Short Haul Team has now trained in the winter environment, at altitude, and so becomes another tool for the Winter Rescue Team.

If you use the Barnes’ La Sal Rec map, notice it has not one coordinate along the map margin. All the lines are there, just no numbers. You need to label your own coordinates. Shows ski routes.

Pilot: John Ruhl
Spotters: Kent Green and Curt Brewer
Short Haul Team: Bego, Curt Brewer, Frank Mendonca, Steve White, Kent Green, Corky Brewer

La Sal Avalanche Forecast Center:   www.avalanche.org/~lsafc
The coolest thing is that Faerthen Felix is the forecaster again.

Go to---> Winter Rescue Team meetings and trainings

See 'em online : www.avalanche.org/~lsafc

********** November 14, 1998 **********

98- 69 11- 14- 98 Ambulance Assist - Biker Stuff SRBT IC = 1 T Rex
The call came for GCSAR to respond to a broken ankle. The ATVs were half way to the trailhead when 10-22d. The biker refused any treatment or transport when he learned it would cost him money.

Responders:  Rex, Kurt, Jeff, Mark, John F.

98-718 - Canyonlands NP (UT) - Assist; Climbing Fatality
On the morning of November 14th, rangers received a report of an apparent climbing fatality in Indian Creek Canyon, a popular climbing destination on BLM land just outside the park's Needles District. They found the body of 41-year-old Paul Hubbs of Telluride, Colorado, at the base of "The Naked and the Dead" climbing route. Park Service personnel conducted a scree evacuation of the body for the county sheriff's department and assisted in the investigation. Evidence indicates that Hubbs had been solo climbing late on the previous evening and that his one-piece anchor pulled out as he was rappelling off the route. He fell about 30 feet and suffered extensive injuries.

[Fred Patton, DR, CANY, 11/5]

Notes from a local bike shop whiz kid about rescues and the Tramway:
The tramway to Moab Rim project has begun. This will ultimately result in many more Search and Rescue call-outs for injured and lost bikers- because:

An emergent group of mountain bikers is the "ski lift bikers." In the summer, these folks, usually families or the more daredevil X-game types, ride ski lifts to the summits and bike downhill. Soon, we will have the lift. And many people taking their bikes up to the rim. Some will ride down the treacherous Moab Rim Trail (jeep 4+), thinking it’s an easy route. New "downhill bike" runs will be developed by usage that lead down into Pritchett Canyon. It will be difficult to help injured people in some of these areas. Some of this land is too rugged for our 6 wheelers. Even the short haul team would have problems. We must Be Prepared.

A "LIFT EVACUATION PLAN" will evolve in January. Interested? Go to Brad and Kenny. Many Hours of arduous training in Feb and Mar. Demo for OSHA in March. Woosh!!

H. A. T. E. -- another, yet another, acronym. (From Rock and Ice, #89, p40, author from Ohio)
The article starts out with this: "If you and I ever get a chance to climb together, I will HATE myself and then I will HATE you."

H. Harness: tight, buckles secure and doubled back, any material frayed or worn (esp at the main tie-in area)??

A. Anchors: at least 2, bombproof, will it hold in any direction, can the belayer be pulled off the stance, water knots with at least 2" of tail, wear marks or frayed marks on anything, faded??

T. Tie-in: correct knot, does it loop thru the leg loops and the waist belt, is the rope worn or frayed, esp about 15’ from the end??

E. Equipment: biners, slings, pro, belay and rap devices, prusik loop in good shape and rigged properly? Am I carrying enuff personal items for the project, even if the weather turns??

********** November 23, 1998 **********

98- 70 11- 23- 98 Cell Phone Rescue Golden Spike Trail IC = 1 T 6
"Received a cell phone call stating that they were on the Golden Spike Trail with 1 broken jeep and they were lost. I asked if they had matches and they said yes. I said to spend the night and if you can’t find a way out, call."

Responders:  Kent

********** November 24, 1998 **********

GCSAR meeting 11- 24- 98
Training: We’re all CPR Thanks to Kenny, John, Aug, Rena

********** December 3, 1998 **********

98- 71 12- 3- 98 Pipeline Go BOOM Hwy 191 (5 mi N of Moab)
"There are some inherent dangers." - K. Guymon, Williams Energy at an LEPC meeting.

98-742 - Arches NP (UT) - Pipeline Explosion; Park Evacuation, Closure

A gas pipeline explosion occurred less than a half mile north of the park's visitor center and main entrance on Highway 191 just before 10 a.m. on December 3rd. A construction crew installing a new gas pipeline ruptured an existing ten-inch line carrying unrefined natural gas liquids. Workers heard the sound of escaping gas and fled; shortly thereafter, the gas ignited, creating a fireball and plume of black smoke visible for miles. Rangers heard the explosion and contacted the county sheriff's office. A 150-foot high column of flame was visible above the 200-foot high ridge directly in front of the visitor center, but the ridge prevented substantial and possibly catastrophic damage to the park's headquarters area and injury to park visitors and employees who reside there. The entire area was immediately evacuated, and gas and electrical services were shut off. Visitors and employees already in the park were prevented from entering the area and had to either exit the park via backcountry roads or spend the night in the park campground. An immediate interagency response ensued. Over 100 fire, EMS, SAR, hazmat and law enforcement personnel from about 20 agencies with a 200- mile radius of the incident responded. The incident was managed under a unified interagency command. There were initial reports of up to 20 fatalities, but these proved incorrect - three pipeline workers received minor injuries and a fourth was hospitalized with internal injuries. A D-8 Caterpillar bulldozer and eight other motor vehicles were incinerated in the blaze, and a tractor-trailer traveling over the highway was damaged. Damage to park resources included destruction of all vegetation covering about 50 acres and loss of a number of park boundary signs. Highway 191 was closed for a day and a half, and nearby high voltage electric transmission lines were shutdown for two days. Media interest in the incident was very high. Twenty-eight NPS employees from Arches and Canyonlands NPS responded; several filled key overhead positions and the remainder provided EMS, park security, traffic control, spotter aircraft overflights, public information, and family liaison. Eight park residents were evacuated from their homes for two days, with most housed in local motels. The park remained closed and the headquarters complex remained evacuated until repairs to the pipeline were completed in the early morning hours of December 5th. The park returned to normal operations later that morning.

[Gary Haynes and Jim Webster, ARCH, 12/6]

GCSAR responders: Frank, Brad, Lloyd, Kent, Kenny, Jimmy N., Russel, Kris, Steve, Josh, Rex, Dave M., sam, Dan, Lee, Kurt, Richard, Greg, Jimmy F., Kim the mom, Nancy, Jennie, Dean, Aug, Dave L., Jeff, Mark, George, John.

Cellular Phone Location Identification- "Fonefinder
From: Jim Webster
Author: Ken Phillips at NP-GRCA SAR Coordinator Grand Canyon National Park 12/2/98

Cellular Telephone 911 Call Location Identification- "Fonefinder" manufactured by Tendler Cellular, Boston, MA

The FCC issued a Report and Order requiring all cellular service providers and manufacturers to identify the location of 911 calls. The two possible solutions have been to install directional beacons on all cellular towers (cost prohibitive at $50k to $500k per site) or enhance the cellular phones to provide a location.

Tendler Cellular of Boston, MA has developed and patented the "fonefinder" system for reporting to dispatch centers the location of a stricken individual through telling the Dispatcher in English where the caller is. This is done through "voice" synthesis chip which transmits the location of the phone in latitude/longitude coordinates. The location is determined through by a GPS chip built into the phone. This location identification feature is only activated when a distinctive "911" button on the phone is pushed to make an emergency call to a 911 PSAP (Public Safety Answering Point). The fonefinder chip sets are already being installed by phone manufacturers including Mitsubishi, Audiovox, Nokia, Motorola and Ericcson. The price for phone with this feature is expected to be $400 each.

This technology heightens the need for NPS park dispatches facilities to get on line with electronic maps to determine Lat/Long coordinates immediately. Several products are readily available, such as Delorme, Tactical Mapping, TOPO!, and Maptech.

More information on the fonefinder is available at- www.fonefinder.com/intro.html

Subject: "The future vs. wilderness" Electronic gadgetry vs knowing.
From: Mike Hill *Forest Gump was quoted as saying....."stupid is as stupid does...." *Electronics could actually amplify Darwinism......before breeding. *Tools of any type are dangerous in the hands of fools and idiots. People will continue to get into trouble in the wilderness, especially if they're only partially equipped ....mentally, physically and spiritually. Unfortunately people tend to think they can pick up the slack of any these qualities - financially.

From: Paul Cowan This just proves you still need to know how to use a map and compass when the batteries in your GPS unit and cell phone die.

From: Bob Proudman Date: 12/11/98 Dear Mr. Walters: Don Owen of the A.T. Park Office (NPS), shared with me a hard-copy of your email about MAPTECH, Inc. and the implications of modern mapping and cell phone technologies on the wilderness. I thought you'd enjoy an article I wrote on the subject, published in our maintainers' newsletter THE REGISTER, in the spring of 1997. It was well-received by our readers. Bob

Cell Phones and GPS Will Never Replace Outdoor Experience and Training

Modern electronic gadgetry such as the cell phone and the global positioning system (GPS) are not always a boon to safety, and may actually overload rescue services with unnecessary, nonemergency communications from hikers who should be better prepared and more traditionally equipped with map, compass and hiking gear appropriate for the terrain and season. This is the theme of an article published last year by the Wall Street Journal, "Annoying in the City, Cell Phones Are Hell In the Wilderness," which recounts a number of disturbing incidents last summer in New Hampshire's White Mountains and elsewhere. Two hikers from Pennsylvania equipped with a cell phone and global positioning system, but no map, repeatedly checked with rescuers as they climbed Mount Tripyramid. While they knew their latitude and longitude, they didn't have a map to plot their position or course. A rescue was launched to guide them out during a pouring rain despite the fact that they were not injured or ill from exposure. In another more outlandish situation, the National Park Service tells of a hiker who requested a helicopter rescue in Olympic National Park last summer. The man was a day behind schedule and anxious to get to a business meeting. When he was informed by park rangers that a helicopter rescue would cost him $1500, his requests abruptly ceased. Similar incidents are being reported by more and more rescue agencies as cell phones and GPS systems are becoming more affordable. (Clubs or agencies with interesting stories are encouraged to write ATC at the masthead address.)

What is most disturbing about these reports is the incompetence of some of the parties requesting aid or rescue. In one case, a pair of hikers called for assistance at 5:30 a.m. after shivering through the night on Mt. Flume because they couldn't light their cook stove or didn't understand that their space blanket, which they had with them, could help keep them warm. Hearing that help was on the way, one of them claimed "this helped my morale a lot." Would his morale be helped even more if he learned the skills for staying warm, dry, well-fed and located in the backcountry? Phoning for help or knowing one's satellite location does absolutely no good if you can't discern a trail junction, put on warm clothes or prepare something hot to eat and drink. Cell phones and global positioning systems may lull hikers with false security, leading to forging ahead in marginal weather or without adequate equipment to stay warm, well fed and prepared to wait-out storms or find the way by headlamp after nightfall.

Rescue agencies are quickly getting more savvy in their dealings with hikers who "cry wolf" prematurely, demanding rescues and other assistance. AMC Outdoors reported several years ago about a pair of New York hikers who became lost in a dense November fog below Mt. Washington. They called AMC several times on their cell phone, tying up the line when there was no real emergency. Because they were uninjured, AMC declined to help them, except to advise them on their best route out. The hikers found their way off the mountain using map and compass which, fortunately, they were carrying with them.

Over the years, New Hampshire residents and their state legislative representatives have grown impatient with the high costs of rescues in the White Mountain National Forest, the costs for which are paid mostly by New Hampshire's Fish and Game Department, a state agency funded by revenues from hunting and fishing licenses. According to a late-1996 article in the New Hampshire Sunday News, the legislature passed a law that will allow the Fish and Game Department to fine hikers whose negligence leads to a rescue situation. State officials may charge rescue costs on the perpetrator if his negligence caused the rescue. This provision has only been used once, to fine a hiker who became hypothermic after getting drunk on Mt. Moriah. Other hikers bundled him up in a sleeping bag and space blanket, and he was evacuated the next day by the state. For his foolishness, he pled guilty to reckless conduct and was fined $500.

The Roanoke Times recently carried a commendable editorial entitled, "Technology threatens sanctity of wild places." It describes how techno-fanatics who love cell phones, GPS units, portable radios, TVs and other electronic gadgetry, will potentially undermine the wilderness ethic. Author Justin Askins ends his article with a warning that "wilderness should be left out of the computer age." While I agree with Mr. Askins' philosophy, I find myself pessimistic about our collective ability to discourage sophisticated electronic toys. In my opinion, people will always be people, and will usually succumb to the temptation to bring new gizmos into the woods. Certainly, peer pressure should be brought to bear to limit the noise of audio equipment, and outright bans might even become necessary if there are repeating patterns of egregious electronic noise disrupting others' solitude and recreation experience.

In the end, the human propensity to be infatuated with gadgetry actually has little to do with real competence in hiking in different seasons or marginal weather conditions. Despite the most sophisticated equipment, I remain confident that people-in their infinitely various ways-will continue to venture outdoors with unfailing incompetence. In the final analysis, hikers will have to become competent to stay out of trouble, or to "self-rescue," particularly when bad weather hampers communications or a response from prospective rescuers. If hikers don't become competent, they may be confronted with the absolute necessity to manage their situation in the throes of a real emergency regardless of the equipment they're carrying.

Search, rescue and law-enforcement personnel will need to be prepared for the likelihood of receiving more premature calls, and consider encouraging their legislatures and administrative supervisors to pass search and rescues costs along to the victims, particularly in cases of outright negligence. Land managing agencies should also prepare more effective warnings that clarify the essential message: visitors must use mountains and trails "by their own unaided efforts" or be prepared to pay. Maybe it is time to state, unequivocally, that nonessential emergency communications may constitute interference with government agency functioning, an act that is considered illegal in most jurisdictions, and to consider levying fines on the worst offenders.

Bob Proudman, Trail Management Dir, Appalachian Trail Conf, Harpers Ferry, WV 25425

98-696 - Grand Teton NP (WY) - SHORT HAUL Rescue
On the afternoon of October 12th, rangers received a phone call from Barbara Lachmar of Logan, Utah, reporting that her husband, Tom, had not returned from a climb in the Tetons. Lachmar left his residence in Logan on the night of the 10th with plans to solo climb the next day, then return home that evening. He left no information as to what route or peak he was intending to climb, or at which parking area he would leave his vehicle. Rangers located Lachmar's vehicle at the String Lake trailhead just before 5 p.m., thereby narrowing down the search area to the central portion of the Teton Range.

Shortly thereafter, two rangers began an aerial search in the park contract helicopter, with plans to fly primary trails and travel routes and to look for an attractant such as smoke or a mirror flash. Ten minutes into the flight, they spotted a white t-shirt hanging in a tree near the base of Symmetry Couloir, southeast of Symmetry Spire. Although it turned out that this shirt had nothing to do with the missing climber, it focused the aerial search in this general area.

Within two minutes, a solo climber was seen in the upper reaches of a couloir west of Symmetry Spire. The individual matched the description of the missing climber; he appeared to be injured and unable to move. With daylight hours waning, the helicopter returned to the Lupine Meadows helibase and was configured for a shorthaul rescue. One ranger served as the shorthaul spotter while the other was lowered to the scene via a 150-foot shorthaul line. The climber, who turned out to be Lachmar, was stabilized and evacuated via shorthaul extraction, with a ranger attending him.

Just under three hours had elapsed since the first report. This proved significant, as the search was begun with the knowledge that Lachmar had gone climbing somewhere in the Tetons and was likely in the central portion of the Teton Range. It's estimated that a conventional, technical ground rescue to the nearest landing zone would have required, at a minimum, a team of 12 to 15 people, and would have extended well into the following day.

[C. Campbell, CR, GRTE, 10/22]

********** December 8, 1998 **********

12- 8- 98 GCSAR Meeting and Elections
Dave Bodner, rescue guru in about any field, taught about Winter Snow and Avies